The SHOOTOUT RETURNETH!

Due to popular demand, and my own lame-ness, I present, the new, downgraded M1700 / Sahara I440D Slate TabletPc Shootout!

Now in deluxe cartoon-o-review-vision, with a severe lack of information, and photographs! W00T. (Click for biggy versions.)

aaa001.jpg

aaa002.jpg

aaa003.jpg

aaa004.jpg
aaa006.jpg

17 comments

  • Considering I’m looking at both of these as possible sketching/drawing options in case my ModBook never comes, I’m glad to hear you liked the i440D… I was wondering how it faired as a drawing tool… is that what you ended up with?

  • Hmm.. I would say, in general, the I440D fared pretty well. The plastic overlay made me a tiny bit nervous, (as if gradually, it would wear away, and render the touchscreen, at least, useless. Although it seemed very very TOUGH.)

    I just had it for review for a short period of time, but yes, I think overall, my opinion has changed. I really liked the build and feel of the Sahara over the new (1600 and on) Motion Slates. I guess the older Sahara, (I forget which model) single core slate, was pretty fancy and light compared to the Motion M1400 at the time, but didn’t get as much press. The I440D, a bit thicker, but very well done. Liked the loud stereo speakers on it too, and overall friendly feel.

    I think given a 2nd chance, I would have gone Sahara over Motion. Hoping for a slate pc based on that flat lil’ intel chip that resides in the current Mac airbook, with NON REPLACABLE USER BATTERY. Doh! Oh Apple.. you slay me.
    :-)
    C

  • Hey Chad, thanks again! Any thoughts on the Scribbler 4000?
    There’s a bunch of us desperate to get our ModBook orders fulfilled but it’s been slow coming… it’s very frustrating when there ARE no options for us Apple geeks ;)

  • Hey! Blackflux: Yep, somewhere, I do have those pictures. I’ll post them up this evening.

    Amy: Hmm.. to the best of my knowlege, the Scribbler looks to be a fantastic machine. Similar to the I440d minus the touchscreen. Looks a bit thinner too.

    I would caution you against running Vista, get XP, of course.. and if you buy an external DVD drive, I bet you could download a copy of OSX Leopard for Intel, from thee olde piratebayyy and install OSX on it. Did I mention I actually had OSX 10.4.8 running on my old motion M1400, with the pen working fully?

    I ultimately went back to XP, because I happen to really not like OSX a whole lot, and couldn’t get the wifi or sound to work properly.

    However, I do know that getting the networking, sound etc, is all possible on PC hardware, if you have a geeky enough pal to help you. I’ve done it on desktop hardware too. Had things 100% working there. ..

    Good luck!
    C

  • over at the modbook forum one guy already returned his Modbook because of eratic pen behavior.(also the blue tooth does not work, nor portrait mode and battery life is only 2 hours) I canceled my order and looking at PC tablets and that is how I found this site!

  • So the Sahara won out huh?
    Hmmm. I’ve been eying getting a new Tablet and was going to go with the Le1700 but you say it’s too hot to hold?
    I was messing with a TX1000 at Fry’s yesterday and I hated the spongy screen and I also hated the touchscreen because my hand kept touching more than one thing. I even loaded SBP on it and it sucked. It also made me nervous. I guess there’s just really no perfect tablet.

  • Those photos are gone, gone gone. Sorry!

    The LE1700.. well.. at some point ALL motion machines get a bit too hot for my tastes. Will they actually burn your hands? Let’s just say, at full power, on a warm day.. they get pretty hot. On bare legs, they can easily be too hot, and cause feelings of ouch-ocity.

    Yeah! I think the Sahara won out. I can get past drawing on the touchscreen plastic-y spongy screen. It wasn’t too bad really. For the record, I own a Cintiq 21″ and the newer widescreen model, and the widescreen model ($2000) has parallax issues! Really disappointed with how incorrect the cursor is at the screen edges.
    It’s workable, but for the money, I would really probably take a chance on one of THESE: http://www.kdsusa.com/visboard.asp

    Hmm.. there’s a place that sells them in my area.. maybe I’ll get one and do a review..
    C

  • Whoah! that thing ROCKS! Yes please please please do a review! I will buy one of those on the spot! They’re only like $500! Amazing really. I wonder if the digitizer is good enough to draw with or if it’s just basic presenation kinda thing. Have you seen any reviews?

  • Hey Mike: Just got off the phone with someone at KDS, and it looks like they have one set up out in their office, (no retail store) -and someone is going to get back to me about the possibility of me going out there and getting a live demo.

    They say I could install a few apps, like demos of Flash, Photoshop, and Painter to test pressure sensitivity in all those apps.

    I plan on taking my DSLR and doing a little review of the product for them.
    Stay tuned!
    C

  • Awesome! That’d be great! I can’t wait! I’m drooling. Shocking to hear about the Cintiq being off. those things are so overpriced. If this thing for real, I’ll buy one tomorrow. I saw the pen is battery so I’m wondering if it really works well enough. Honestly I’d be surprised if it did.

  • I think that the pen battery thing is only due to a patent on the battery-less pen that wacom holds. The way it works, is that the pen is actually powered by the small electromagnetic current / field that the screen digitizer gives off, charging and activating the little pen’s capacitors.. Heard that from one of the guys at wacom.
    Found a post somewhere in dutch that claims that the Visboard will have a battery-less pen next year when Wacom’s patent runs out.
    ??! At any rate, I’m sure it works just as well. I’ve used battery driven pens in the past, and they were just a tiny bit more heavy than the wacom stylus.
    -C

  • Chad I was going through my computer organizing files/stuff and I found your original review with pictures. I guess I loved it so much that I saved it. I can zip it and send it to you if you like.

    On another note, I just purchased the Cintiq 20WSX and I’m really disappointed with the calibration of the cursor at the screen edges (top right and bottom left). I was surprised that it only uses a 2 point calibration versus the Tablet PC 4 point calibration. I’ve only had it for one night and I am about to ship it back (I’ll give it a week). The only way I can exit out of a application is if I do file > close. That’s pretty sad.

Leave a Reply